The League: Part 1 - Whats Wrong With Semi-Pro

None posted by: by Eric Satterwhite on Thu Mar 19 2009
In A 2 Part Series I Take Serious Look At The Pro's And Con's To The Ironman Football League

Call it what you will; AAA, Minor League, Semi-Pro, Old-Man, Bar League, or whatever. This level of football ( semi-pro ), where athletes beyond their high school playing days play with out compensation - in the state of Wisconsin, it has a strange vibe to it. It's a love / hate kind of a vibe. Wisconsinites Love them some football. When the Green Bay Packers, Wisconsin Badgers or [ INSERT FAVORITE HIGH SCHOOL TEAM HERE ] are playing, you will be hard pressed to find people doing something other than watching the game. It's what we do here - watch football! Everyone loves a good game, even if they don't know whats going on. People just love to get involved.

Even when the Muskego Hitmen play...wait...hold on...Who?

I think I've heard of you...Do you guys play the Racine Raiders?

No, no we don't play the Raiders...We play the Venom...The Rush?...Bueller? People just don't seem to pay much attention to the Semi-Pro ranks. And a lot of it has to do with a bad reputation of  poorly run teams taking sponsor money only to fold due to many reasons usually stemming from a league run just as bad, if not worse.  There is a laundry list of teams and leagues that have come and gone that is too long to list. However, The Ironman Football League is starting to rub a little bit of the tarnish off of the armor.  The IFL has made some huge gains in the semi-pro football ranks in a very short time. This League does a lot of things right and just as many things wrong.

As with anything, you tend to hear about the bad before you hear about the good. Yes, the IFL has taken a ton of heat from players and teams past, present and even those who are thinking of joining the league. So I'm going to give you my perspective on the IFL and my take on how things are done on and off the field. Keeping in line with tradition - The Bad before The Good:

Whats Wrong With Semi-Pro

Over Aggressiveness

The officials of the IFL have a reputation being overly aggressive when it comes to making decisions that have a significant impact not only the league, but the Teams, owners and coaches. They have a "Ready, FIRE, Aim" mentality in many cases. In most recent history, A prime example would be the situation with the Ironbowl. Before the season actually starts, the date, time, and place of the Ironbowl for that season is determined. In the 2008 season, The "Rights" to the Ironbowl were sold in week 9 of the season effectively moving the location of the Ironbowl to the home field of the Madison Mustangs, who were a shoe in as Ironbowl Contender that year.

The league had proposed the idea of selling game rights in league meetings prior to the season, however no one showed interest. Or I should say, no one showed interest until week 9 of the season. To make matters worse - Good Ole Mad-Town has deeper pockets than everyone else. No one stood a chance to out bid them. The decision was made, the deal was done and THEN the announcement was made. Ready, FIRE, Aim. These kinds of things happen frequently. There is at least one major occurrence every year. Things are on the up and up with the addition of Dan Greene to the front office, But I will save that topic for part II.

It Costs How Much?!

Running a football team is not cheap. I know that - You know that, but in the IFL it's more. No...More than that. A team in IFL will spend more money in 3 months than the average American makes in a year ( Pre-Economic Crisis ). If you are a 1st year start up team - you might as well double that. Well OK, not that much, but it's close - really close. The front office of the team really needs to be on their game when it comes to finding sources of income. I can tell you this much, we don't count $5 tickets and $2 hot dogs income.

To top it off, it is getting more expensive. The IFL is pushing it's new game format of: teams should have a home field; meaning you need to rent a field to play on. Teams also have to pay for their own refs, the league doesn't pay for that. I can only speak for the Hitmen; playing at InPro Stadium, in that when it is all said and done, a home game will cost about $1000 - $1200, all things included. That is a lot of hot dogs my friend. The Hitmen usually have 4 or so home games so you can do that math. And this is just to play the games. 

Here is the kicker, With all of the costs more or less passed off on to the teams, there is still a $2000 league fee. It Costs How Much?! 

A "Professional" League

There are many ways to define what is professional and what is not. In sports it tends to be defined by if the athletes are paid or not. If you get paid, you're professional, if you don't get paid, you are not. It's pretty cut and dry. I would argue that - there are a lot of "Professional" leagues / teams out there that are far from professional. The 2008 Bonecrushers would be a prime example of that.  However, in the IFL's case, they mean professional in the way that the league and it's teams are run.  The league does a good job at presenting a pretty good final product ( the games ), mainly do to, again, with the work of the teams & their front offices. However, any league's image is only as professional as the people who make it up. One of the unfortunate things with the IFL happens to be its list of disgruntled team owners and in some cases current owners and players.

What makes it unfortunate is that they will take every chance they get to try to bring the IFL down. Trying to take teams from the league, legal action, and one owner went as far as to create a website to use as a public venue to openly bash the IFL and it's officials. All of these things come off as childish and immature and I think in many cases holds the league back -  It certainly doesn't help.  In any event, the league still stands. And I think only lends to it's credit.  One of the major problems is that the league tends to put itself up on a public forum and even will try to fight fire with fire in some of these cases.  I'm not aware of many other leagues where the owner and commissioner have such a hands-on approach with it's teams.

I say, let the kids be kids and just move on.

The Complex

Fields in general tend to be a problem for Semi-Pro Teams. No one wants to let them use it. They know the league will try to squeeze as many games in as few days as possible and will need to be repaired before anyone else can use it. Its a costs vs benefits thing. The  Milwaukee County Sports Complex has been the IFL's "Go To" field for a number of years. There is a lot of history with this stadium. Today, teams are being encouraged to seek out their own playing fields and stadiums. However, despite the effort,  The IFL hasn't grown past this eye sore of a football field.

It wasn't originally designed as a football field, it isn't pitched right. I don't think it has a pitch at all. When it rains, the water just sits on the field and takes some serious abuse. Before the league went to the new scheduling format, by the end of a season, that field wasn't even a field anymore, it was just mud. There are spots where the grass doesn't even grow back and there a metal grates scattered around the field. We can do with out this field, and it would cut back on the league budget. If a team wants to claim the complex as their home field, let them do that. In reality, I think providing a stadium on a weekly basis should not be on the shoulders of the league. 

The Competition

This one is pretty cut and dry. There are too many leagues and too many players confined to too much of a small  area. Do you know what the hottest trend in Semi-Pro Football in Wisconsin is? Quit your team, and start your own! It's like making a movie based on comic books. EVERYONE is doing it. I can't even begin to tell you how many leagues, or divisions of a league or teams there are in Wisconsin. Take the IFL for instance -  Roughly 10 teams in the greater Milwaukee area in any given year. This makes it hard for teams to maintain a quality roster. From year to year, teams don't really get new players they just rotate from team to team.  When one team can't get players to rotate over to their side, they just fold and merge into another team that is already struggling. Then one of the players from one of those teams, branches off and starts their own team in just about the same spot.

It is a wonder that teams are able to stay a float, let alone progress in the semi-pro ranks. If there is such a thing.  The Racine Raiders stand out because they have been the same team in the same place for decades.  Just like the term "Atkins" has become synannomous with eating bacon and cheese, the Raiders always come to mind when people hear minor league / semi-pro football. I think teams like the Muskego Hitmen, Madison Mustangs and Roscoe Rush are making a little hedgeway on the issue.

Filed Under:
  • ifl
  • ironbowl
  • semi-pro

  • Brad on: 26 Mar 2009
    Die Hard Fan
    it is unfortunate that good football like this doesn't come cheap. but i have a feeling that everything mr. chudada does is for the betterment of the league. televised games and new sponsors.why someone would have a site that bashes the ifl is about as stupid as the that website and what is really wrong with the milwaukee sports complex? i was there for the playoff game that we lost last season and i saw nothing wrong with the milwaukee sports complex. except for the fact that i had to stand just to see over the venom players.
    Eric Satterwhite on: 26 Mar 2009
    Defensive End #90
    i think my points about the complex are more than valid. and you are right - someone making a website to bash the league is stupid. that was my point exactly...maybe you skipped over those parts?
    Brad on: 27 Mar 2009
    Die Hard Fan
    well, maybe you would know more about the complex than me since you have played more but i have a feeling that things are about to change for the better.

    Recent Blogs

    Always A Hitmen
    posted by Jason Huckstorf on Feb 04 2010
    players greed gets in the way of championships
    What Makes Semi-Pro Football Great In A Fan's Eyes
    posted by Hitwarrior2008 on Jun 10 2009
    How I see semi-pro football as a fan
    The Pitch
    posted by Jake Klipp on May 28 2009
    These are a few of my favorite things...
    Profile Picture Blunder
    posted by Eric Satterwhite on May 27 2009
    I scrubbed a little too hard during some spring cleaning
    Orthopaedic Associates Of Wisconsin
    posted by Andrew Janatis on May 16 2009
    A Thanks To My Sponsors
    Windlake Street Fair
    posted by Diane on May 08 2009
    Dance Team Promo/Appearance
    The List Grows On....
    posted by Steve Miick on Apr 19 2009
    I can't stay away.
    Smashmouth Magazine: The Process
    posted by Eric Satterwhite on Apr 14 2009
    Get a behind the scenes look at the making of Smashmouth Volume 2
    The Monarchs Set The Bar
    posted by Eric Satterwhite on Apr 10 2009
    The Monarch's Set New Standards In Front Office Management
    First Practice
    posted by Matt Nelson on Apr 05 2009
    First Practice thoughts
    The Web Is Killing Internet Explorer
    posted by Eric Satterwhite on Apr 01 2009
    See! I'm not the only one that hates Internet Explorer
    Explosion Dancers
    posted by Diane on Apr 01 2009
    Explosion Dance Team
    Iron Pictures
    posted by Jeff Ernst on Mar 30 2009
    Till Next Time
    Hitmen History Update
    posted by Eric Satterwhite on Mar 28 2009
    I had a couple hours of life to burn up so I contiued down the ole' memory lane
    posted by Steve Miick on Mar 28 2009
    IRONBOWL 2009
    The League: Part 2 - What Is Right With Semi-Pro
    posted by Eric Satterwhite on Mar 26 2009
    The conclusion of the two part series which takes a critical look at how much pro is really in Semi-Pro
    It All Started With Craigslist
    posted by Jeff Ernst on Mar 26 2009
    Fate is a funny thing
    What It Means To Be A Hitmen
    posted by Nick Seliger on Mar 23 2009
    Let's get serious
    Weekly Tech Talk: Survey Says...
    posted by Eric Satterwhite on Mar 22 2009 moves up the all powerful Google Ladder
    Old School Hitmen
    posted by Eric Satterwhite on Mar 19 2009
    Going back in time and digging up things from the past
    The Ifl To Change All-Star Voting?
    posted by Eric Satterwhite on Mar 17 2009
    Many team owners are pushing to change the all-star voting process
    Satterwhite Is The Man!
    posted by Jason Blawat on Mar 16 2009
    Thanks, Eric.
    A Whole Mess Of Photos
    posted by Eric Satterwhite on Mar 16 2009
    I uploaded a ton of stuff and made a video
    It's A Website
    posted by Eric Satterwhite on Mar 15 2009
    Call it ranting or venting, but you can listen to me talk about how the website came to be