The Ifl To Change All-Star Voting?

None posted by: by Eric Satterwhite on Tue Mar 17 2009
Many Team Owners Are Pushing To Change The All-Star Voting Process

Anytime there is an election where a large group of people involved in either the voting process or, of course the people being elected, have a gripe with the process. And as coincidence would have it, it tends to be the group of people that do not win that have the grip. When it comes the the IFL All-Star voting process, there is a slight conflict of interest. As it turns out, the Players are the ones nominating the players. Yeah, it's a little backwards, but the fine print says that players can't vote for people on their same team and you can only vote for people in the same conference as your team resides.

The primary gripe with this process is that many players play favorites or that a lot of people are nominated on reputation. Which is true in a lot of cases - It happens all the time in ANY voting process. As a player I have had the pleasure to sit in on a number of these voting sessions and they aren't very organized. In many cases, it comes down to, "That guy kicked my @$$" - Mark Him Down! To make matters worse, With the new league format of all of the teams playing on Saturday night, at about the same time, and no double headers - The likely hood that any of the players actually get to see many teams / players is going to come down to who they line up against on Saturday night. 

The Solution?

Many owners have come to the conclusion that All-star voting should be based on stats. Okay...but there are a couple of inherent problems with this.

  • Every team keeps different stats
  • every team's stats guy is counting things differently
  • Most Stat guys are there because they can get a free ticket to watch a football game
  • Most of the positions on the field require information that is not typically tracked.

For the majority of the reasons listed, Team owners have suggested that the league adopt a unified way to keep track of the and have standards in place to do so. Great! That's lovely. And I'm sure that would work the way you would expect. For a QB, you need TDs, Total Yards, Interceptions, etc. And this would work out for the "skilled" positions. However, being one of the non-skilled players myself, I have a bit of a problem with this

Back To The Future

No one keeps stats on us. As far as the defensive line is concerned People care about tackles and sacks, and sacks tend to stand out more than tackles. But that is not all we do for a defense, and that is not how you should measure a player's worth to a team. Are the best 3 Linebackers the ones that have the most Tackles? or the most Sacks? In the case of a defensive lineman, what about pressures, or QB hurries, tackle for a loss; and the yards racked up from tackles for a loss. If the league were to use stats as the primary gauge, they would need a very specific set of criteria each player must meet to be eligible for the all-start nod.  This is stuff that NO ONE at this level of football keeps track of  nor wants to do.  Can you imagine the amount of man-power it would take to watch everything that every position were doing on a weekly basis for every team. Especially when all of the gamers are at different locations. And if one were to use stats to determine All-Stars, I would think one would need to start. Otherwise, we are back to square one, which guy really kicked my @$$?

The Flip Side

Lets look at the Flip Side. Offensive Line. No one keeps stats on the offensive line, if they do, it's pancake blocks...and that's it. What about Missed blocks, blocks for a big gain, block for a touchdown, sacks allowed and on and on and on. Put that into perspective - 1 Center, 2 Guards, 2 Tackles, Possibly a TE who is more of a block than a receiver, and in this league, the fullback rarely sees the ball, so they are usually considered an extra blocker. If you are counting that is at least 5 and possibly 7 out of a possible 11 players who have not statistical records to use for this "All-Star" Voting. You're basically looking at QB's, Tailbacks and receivers.

Beggars Can't Be Choosers

I think the biggest problem is leaving the decisions up to the teams. Obviously everyone likes to think their entire roster is full of all-stars. Players have a hard time putting pride aside and making the right call. Don't get me wrong, there are a lot of cases when Players are picked because they are hands down one of the best in the league. It is the year after that person is picked that the favoritism starts. For example in 2008, Brad Dement was elected to the 2008 All-Star team and he only played 2 or 3 games! How does that happen?

Either way, numbers don't tell the story. They never have and they never will. They certainly help point you in the right direction, however changing one method to satisfy one angry group will only create another angry group.  No one method will ever be perfect nor will it ever make everyone happy. I for one think leaving it up to the players to nominate other players may not be the smartest move. Are the fans really that involved that they would be able to pick an all-star team? Are they just as biased as the players?  What about from a team stand point; if Team 'A' beats Team 'B' does that mean Team 'A' should get more all-star selections than Team 'B'? I'm sure there are a lot of options other than these two extremes that the league is considering. Who has some ideas?

Filed Under:
  • all-star
  • ifl
    Comments have been disabled for this Article

    grodriguez on: 18 Mar 2009
    Center #62
    i would never be an all-star then.....:( haha
    Eric Satterwhite on: 18 Mar 2009
    Defensive End #90
    maybe if we convince the league to keep track of hip tosses ;)
    McDuffieQB on: 18 Mar 2009
    i am trying to reach carmello. please have him contact jim ******. my email is ********************* thanks and good luck this season!
    Eric Satterwhite on: 18 Mar 2009
    Defensive End #90
    check the faq in the help menu dude...
    McDuffieQB on: 18 Mar 2009
    i tried the pm before i posted on the blog. give me some credit dude, i am somewhat resourceful! :-)
    Eric Satterwhite on: 18 Mar 2009
    Defensive End #90
    wow, you found like 8 bugs in one felt swoop there. but i think i got it fixed. try the pm again, make sure to leave your email address for him there. don't post that stuff on the site.
    grodriguez on: 18 Mar 2009
    Center #62
    that would be nice! :d and we could also do holding calls....
    Brad on: 18 Mar 2009
    Die Hard Fan
    why dont they just do what the nfl does? have the fans vote. now that more games are going to be televised on time warner sports maybe now fans who couldn't make it all the way out for their team's away game can watch their team in action and even get a good look at players from other teams. i understand the fan base still has some growing to do but there should still be enough to where the fans can vote on who makes the all-star teams. or maybe have the head coaches get together and determine all-stars that way. i don't know because i am technically a 2nd year hardcore hitmen fan but it almost seems easier than what the league is making it out to be.
    Eric Satterwhite on: 19 Mar 2009
    Defensive End #90
    i would say a good 70% of a team's fans are either friends or family of a player on that team. not many fans of the hitmen go to non-hitmen games. so if it were fan based, it would come down to who had the most fans at whichever game the voting was done. i think the ifl did try something like that one year? i may be wrong
    Steve Miick on: 21 Mar 2009
    Running Back #32
    is that mcduffie that used to be the qb for the marauders a few years ago???

    Recent Blogs

    Always A Hitmen
    posted by Jason Huckstorf on Feb 04 2010
    players greed gets in the way of championships
    What Makes Semi-Pro Football Great In A Fan's Eyes
    posted by Hitwarrior2008 on Jun 10 2009
    How I see semi-pro football as a fan
    The Pitch
    posted by Jake Klipp on May 28 2009
    These are a few of my favorite things...
    Profile Picture Blunder
    posted by Eric Satterwhite on May 27 2009
    I scrubbed a little too hard during some spring cleaning
    Orthopaedic Associates Of Wisconsin
    posted by Andrew Janatis on May 16 2009
    A Thanks To My Sponsors
    Windlake Street Fair
    posted by Diane on May 08 2009
    Dance Team Promo/Appearance
    The List Grows On....
    posted by Steve Miick on Apr 19 2009
    I can't stay away.
    Smashmouth Magazine: The Process
    posted by Eric Satterwhite on Apr 14 2009
    Get a behind the scenes look at the making of Smashmouth Volume 2
    The Monarchs Set The Bar
    posted by Eric Satterwhite on Apr 10 2009
    The Monarch's Set New Standards In Front Office Management
    First Practice
    posted by Matt Nelson on Apr 05 2009
    First Practice thoughts
    The Web Is Killing Internet Explorer
    posted by Eric Satterwhite on Apr 01 2009
    See! I'm not the only one that hates Internet Explorer
    Explosion Dancers
    posted by Diane on Apr 01 2009
    Explosion Dance Team
    Iron Pictures
    posted by Jeff Ernst on Mar 30 2009
    Till Next Time
    Hitmen History Update
    posted by Eric Satterwhite on Mar 28 2009
    I had a couple hours of life to burn up so I contiued down the ole' memory lane
    posted by Steve Miick on Mar 28 2009
    IRONBOWL 2009
    The League: Part 2 - What Is Right With Semi-Pro
    posted by Eric Satterwhite on Mar 26 2009
    The conclusion of the two part series which takes a critical look at how much pro is really in Semi-Pro
    It All Started With Craigslist
    posted by Jeff Ernst on Mar 26 2009
    Fate is a funny thing
    What It Means To Be A Hitmen
    posted by Nick Seliger on Mar 23 2009
    Let's get serious
    Weekly Tech Talk: Survey Says...
    posted by Eric Satterwhite on Mar 22 2009 moves up the all powerful Google Ladder
    The League: Part 1 - Whats Wrong With Semi-Pro
    posted by Eric Satterwhite on Mar 19 2009
    In a 2 part series I take serious look at the pro's and con's to the Ironman Football League
    Old School Hitmen
    posted by Eric Satterwhite on Mar 19 2009
    Going back in time and digging up things from the past
    Satterwhite Is The Man!
    posted by Jason Blawat on Mar 16 2009
    Thanks, Eric.
    A Whole Mess Of Photos
    posted by Eric Satterwhite on Mar 16 2009
    I uploaded a ton of stuff and made a video
    It's A Website
    posted by Eric Satterwhite on Mar 15 2009
    Call it ranting or venting, but you can listen to me talk about how the website came to be